An ongoing outbreak of X-Disease, associated with ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma pruni’ has resulted in severe economic losses for cherry and stone fruit growers in the U.S. Pacific Northwest in the last decade. Given that this pathogen is transmitted by polyphagous leafhopper species, primarily Colladonus montanus ssp. reductus and C. geminatus in the PNW, alternative plant hosts present a significant management concern. Here we surveyed phytoplasma incidence in non-Prunus plants found in and around stone fruit orchard borders and compared these results to the leafhopper feeding patterns through gut content analysis. We confirmed ‘Ca. P. pruni’ infection in 21 plant species from 15 families. Of these, 15 species were commonly found in the diets of phytoplasma-carrying leafhoppers. Due to the abundance of common species, including Taraxacum, Malva, and Trifolium spp., alternative hosts were found across all growing seasons, although ‘Ca. P. pruni’ titer was low (<102 cells) in most of these hosts. No geographic patterns were identified, instead phytoplasma incidence and spread at individual orchards was related to the management of annual and biennial host species, thus removing preferred leafhopper feeding hosts. These data suggest alternative host removal, along with removal of infected trees, is an effective means of slowing disease spread.