Background/Objective. This study analyzed for the first time the asymptomatic condition induced by CLas in Citrus sinensis / C. aurantium based on initial reports in the Central Gulf region of Mexico. The objective was to analyze with a mechanistic approach the spatial-temporal concentration of CLas at the plant level in commercial orchards to demonstrate the possible implication of a prolonged incubation period in the asymptomatic expression of HLB.
Materials and Methods. Two out of three trees (A1-A3) (>30 years old) of asymptomatic Valencia sweet orange trees positive for CLas, identified through official diagnostic protocols in San José Acateno, Puebla, were confined. On trees A2 and A3, 13 and 16 secondary branches were marked, with a total of 112 and 108 foliage/samples per month, respectively (total 646 samples), obtained from the distal and proximal parts of each branch. Seven monthly samplings of plant material were carried out between May and December. At the root level, three categories were sampled by diameter/function and by a combination of six distal trunk sectors (0 - 280 cm) by 4 in depth (0 x 110 cm) with a total of 111 samples. DNA extraction was performed with 2% CTAB and quantification by RT-qPCR (oligos, HLBp/HLBas).
Results. In canopy, the incidence/branches in A3 was 52.2% (Ct = 22.7 – 34.9), and in A2 47.8% (Ct = 23.4 –35), with no statistical difference (p = 0.48). The inoculum load was 1.6 (±1.3) log-CLas, equivalent to 109 copies/reaction in 100 mL (range in number of copies 6.3 to 68,870.7). CLas did not differ between distal (1.6 log) and proximal (1.5 log) samples (p = 0.33). Significative temporal fluctuation was found between June and October in positive samples (37 – 87, p < 0.0001), but not in CLas concentration (1.6 – 3.5 log-CLas, p > 0.72). The distribution of CLas by branch had a temporal effect (p = 0.0001) and by sector (p = 0.07), showing high mobility and seasonality. The maximum concentration (Ymax) was associated with the middle-upper sector of the canopy, and high mobility towards the lower and upper sectors in Yinitial and Yfinal. In roots, 38.7% positivity was found. The detectability of CLas was homogeneous among root types (p < 0.0001) but variable in concentration (p = 0.04). The 47.6%, 15.4%, and 38.7% incidence was associated with 38.3, 43.4, and 9.5 average CLas copies for support, conduction, and absorption roots, respectively (p = 0.0001). Two sections with higher CLas intensity-concentration (80 – 144 copies) were associated with roots in the middle drip zone (160 – 240 cm) and medium depth strata (50 – 80 cm).
Conclusion. CLas was significantly and consistently detected in plant and root tissue throughout the experimental period, but at fluctuating, non-incremental concentration, analogous between trees A2 and A3. The wide canopy-root distribution suggests a chronic systemic effect. Consequently, the incubation period does not determine the asymptomatic condition in the sweet orange/sour orange productive system investigated. Other factors, e.g. inherent to pathogen variability, could be involved. These results contribute to optimizing a surveillance-monitoring system considering seasonality, zone-branch, sector-canopy and type of tissue, with a greater probability of detection of CLas even in an eventual asymptomatic condition and generate new insights for Clas management.